Top 15 Fleet Management Challenges (and How to Fix Them)

Ever felt like keeping your fleet running smoothly is like trying to change a tire on a moving truck? Trust me, you are not alone. Even a few vehicles are manageable, but once the number grows from five to fifty or more, wheels come off quickly if you are not prepared. If you are going through the same, you’re likely facing fleet management challenges. 

‍

These days, it's not just a matter of going from A to B. Rather, it's about optimizing routes, maintaining compliance, ensuring happy and safe drivers, managing costs, and leveraging technology that doesn't leave you behind. A small victory, surely!

‍

In fact, inefficiency is the biggest headache in any fleet-driven business, and it manifests everywhere, wasting fuel, vehicle downtime, angry drivers, and deadlines. I've watched the complexity grow exponentially without the right system, tools, or mindset.

‍

Whether you are scaling for the very first time or just trying to curb the ever-present chaos, this guide is for you. I am going to walk you through the top 15 challenges that fleet managers face today, from operational and technical barriers to financial pressure and resistance from the people working with them, and, more importantly, how to solve them.

‍

Let's start. 

‍

{{demo_tms="/styles/components"}}

Top fleet management challenges & ways to solve them

Having spent several years in fleet operations, I assure you of this: fleet management isn’t just about keeping vehicles on the road; it’s about keeping the entire system running like clockwork. The problem gets multiplied many times over with scaling. What works for an operation with five vehicles starts to fail when scaling up to 20, 50, or more. Let’s explore each of the challenges and the ways to solve them. 

‍

1. Operational inefficiencies

When an operation is held together through WhatsApp groups, random phone calls, and overloaded Excel sheets, all it takes is a missed update to put chaos in place. I have seen teams dispatching thanks to sticky notes and gut feelings, often ending with missed deliveries, confused drivers, and intense coordination sessions.

‍

Manual dispatch feels feasible on a slow day, but with scaling, it feels like steering a ship without a map. This causes errors in dispatch, creates lags in response, and, worst of all, leads to a blindness to what is on the ground. That’s when customer complaints start rolling in… and you find yourself stuck in reactive mode.

‍

When I discuss this challenge, I can recall a very old story that still feels strikingly familiar today.

Henry Ford was confronted with similar problems in 1913, only forced to ponder in an analog world. The factories at Highland Park had become flourishing, while inside, the materials seemed to be moving in chaos. Workers would fetch the parts from bins. Assemblers would walk to the other end of the room. There had been no standards defining work. Productivity suffered; cancellations were commonplace; and the teams were always playing catch-up. Much like the Excel-overload chaos today, Fords were without real-time visibility and process control.

‍

So, what changed at Ford?

The moving assembly line was set in motion by Henry Ford. Materials were moved towards workers instead of workers going towards the materials. Each step was highly standardized and coordination became proactive instead of being reactive. This reduced assembly time from 12¼ hours to a mere 93 minutes, and the incidence of errors dropped significantly. Read the full story here. 

‍

The key takeaway?

The Ford team needed to stop walking around looking for parts; in a similar sense, your dispatching teams need to stop scrambling for updates. The chaotic missed delivery has always been there; it just had different tools in the past. Replacing gut-feel with a structured approach to digital dispatch, live tracking, and automated alerts is your modern-day Highland Park moment.

‍

‍

Source 

‍

The solution is to centralize operations and digitalize them:

• Use fleet management software or a transport management system for vehicle monitoring and assigning jobs from a single dashboard.
• Build shift calendars to plan driver availability.
• Use digital communication methods to ensure communication between drivers and dispatchers.
• Implement geofencing and route optimization to enhance monitoring and minimize delays. 
• Establish SOPs for escalating failed deliveries, breakdowns, or emergencies.

‍

2. Poor route planning 

When drivers start the day picking routes on the basis of habit or personal shortcuts, there are zigzag deliveries, with fuel waste and extra hours on the road. Backtracking, stops overlapping, and vans stuck in traffic zones that they could have easily avoided due to a lack of prior optimized routing are an everyday occurrence. 

In fact, as per studies, non-optimized routes can increase operational cost by up to 10-30%. Above that, it can also waste your time and money!

‍

What can be done: 

• Use smart route planning tools with real-time traffic integration.
• Group deliveries by zones through clustering.
• Analyze delivery heatmaps to plan efficient daily dispatch loops.
• Give dispatchers visibility into rerouting options in case of traffic jams or delays.

‍

3. High vehicle downtime and breakdowns

When vans break down in the middle of the road, it not only inconveniences the whole delivery chain but also halts the entire operation. These breakdowns become emergencies; sometimes, these can be avoided, but without a service intervention or an early-warning system in place. 

‍

When maintenance becomes solely reactive, your company would be paying more in repair costs and loss of hours of operation. Unplanned downtime is the silent killer of your business, and it is costing companies $448 to $760 per vehicle per day. If you ignore these issues, they will create a vicious cycle of unexpected breakdowns, expensive repairs, angry customers, and an unpredictable work environment. 

‍

What helps:

• Establish a "van-health" score on telematics dashboards. This will alert users to irregularities in tire pressure, brake wear, engine fault codes, and so on.
• Try AI-powered predictive analytics too! This can help forecast any part failure. You can avoid unexpected drop-offs and do service planning in advance.
• Introduce real-time diagnostics and alerting through telematics for predictable van failure or near misses.
• Set up automatic reminders for important maintenance activities.
• Institute preventive maintenance techniques based on engine hours or mileage

‍

4. Poor driver performance and accountability

Another challenge that often flies under the radar is poor driver accountability. If there is no tracking system in place to observe driver behavior like harsh braking, speeding, and idling, this leaves one in the dark. I have witnessed operators wondering if a delay was caused by traffic, poor route selection, or simply distracted drivers who park for 20 minutes at a tea stall.

‍

The bigger problem this creates is when things go astray, because it becomes difficult to assign responsibility. When a delivery is late, is it traffic or inefficient driving? When fuel costs spike, is it route planning or poor throttle control? And when a customer complains? Everyone shrugs.

‍

What helps:

• Use telematics systems to track driver behavior in real-time.
• Create a monthly driver scorecard. Make sure you combine safety, fuel efficiency, and punctuality, and share them openly.
• Hold coaching sessions for drivers tied to actual data, not assumptions. 
• Build incentives for top performers. You can offer fuel bonuses, shift preferences, and recognition. Put your underperformers on a PIP plan or offer them further training on how to improve. 

‍

5. Driver shortage and high attrition

Back in 2023, Jacksonville-based Cypress Trucking gave an alarm: deploying free CDL training plus $70k–$100k starting salaries just to fill seats. With a shortfall of 82,000 drivers being forecasted by the American Trucking Association for 2024, this is not just a recruitment issue; it's a full-fledged talent crisis. The fleets had been unable to keep their trucks rolling because there were simply not enough qualified professionals willing to drive.

‍

The Attrition Problem:

Hiring and retaining pre-trained van drivers is not an easy job. Long hours and last-minute changing shifts are not conducive to career advancement from their perspective. They often see little or no support for safety. Loyalty is tested when sign-on bonuses come knocking at their door, but there is no retention infrastructure backing them up. 

‍

The result?

• Trucks sit idle, and deliveries are delayed or canceled, with revenue disrupted 
• Expensive training and hiring expenditure per driver 
• Burnouts become common while feeding the cycle

‍

The Solution:

• Train your team so that drivers can see a career path in the long run.
• Inject company spirit with mentoring, milestone rewards, and two-way feedback on an ongoing basis.
• Make sure there are equitable shift schedules so that you can easily balance routes and workload.
• Have fuel cards, quality safety gear, and from time to time, offer scheduled breaks.

‍

6. Lack of compliance and documentation

Compliance in van fleet operations is akin to a ticking clock. You never hear it until it stops! I have seen instances where an entire fleet of vehicles was somewhat forcibly grounded for the expiry of a single fitness certificate. The expiry date was never noticed, and the fine arrived days before the renewal reminder.

‍

The fault lies not in negligence, but in fragmentation. Paperwork sits inside mailbox folders or maybe someone’s computer hard drive folder. There is no single place to obtain insurance, emission test results, or inspection logs on demand. So, when an audit is conducted randomly or an accident occurs, that missing piece of paperwork may cost you fines and penalties. Compliance doesn't always have to feel like red tape. When systems are digital, shared, and automated, being ready for audits becomes just another smooth operational process, eliminating all the unnecessary fire drills. 

‍

The solution:

• Build a digital compliance repository where insurance records, permits, licenses, inspection reports, and emission test results for each van are stored in a shared, access-controlled system.
• Set up automated reminders before expiry dates of insurance, pollution checks, fitness certificates, driver's licenses, and safety training records.
• Use pre-trip inspection checklists and driver onboarding checklists to ensure regulatory touchpoints are never overlooked.
• Assign ownership; that is, give one person or team the accountability for ongoing documentation across the fleet.

‍

7. Fuel inefficiency and cost overruns

Fuel inefficiency is not simply wasting a few extra litres. It’s a direct hit to your bottom line!  According to the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI), per-mile costs for fleets increased by 21.3% during the year 2022, with fuel prices alone having experienced a surreal hike of 53.7%, the biggest rise in cost for any single component in that year. 

‍

In a van fleet setup, bad fuel efficiency often results from a mix of excessive idling, overlapping routes, inconsistent driver behavior, and lack of visibility into fuel consumption per vehicle. These inefficiencies, in turn, gradually increase delivery costs, eat into margins, and make route planning more like guesswork.

‍

What helps:

• Train your drivers to practice idle reduction and eco-driving.
• Fuel cards should be issued separately for each van and attached to a physical digital log.
• Route planners can be used to ensure mileage efficiency.
• Use traffic heatmaps to steer clear of bottleneck locations and areas of heavy idling.
• Set alert notifications for idle times through your TMS or fleet telematics system.
• Monitor fuel consumption around each van through dashboards in real time.
• Maintain engine and tire upkeep schedules for proper fuel burning.
• Benchmark fuel efficiency for each vehicle. For example, 24 MPG for cargo vans and 32–43 MPG for larger light-duty vans. Identify the underachievers - anthing that goes below 10-15% should be sent for coaching or technical inspection. 

‍

8. No visibility or real-time tracking

When a van leaves the hub and there’s no way to see where it is, you’re left hoping it all goes as planned. But hope isn’t a strategy. I have observed operations come to a halt with the simple question: "Where's the delivery van right now?"

‍

That visibility problem causes inaccurate ETAs, delayed deliveries, and frustrated clients who usually find out first that something is wrong. And if complaints come in or deliveries get late, there's no way to determine the reason: Was it the traffic? Some detour? Was the driver stopping without permission in his or her own time?

‍

Here’s what you can do:

• Enable geofencing to come in or out of the delivery zones or depots.
• Track logged itineraries and identify potential delays and corroborate these outcomes as part of debriefing or dispute resolutions.
• Use SMS to share live-tracking links with your end customers or to update them with ETA.
• To monitor the position of the vans and the status of the trip, make sure that a fleet-management system is running.
• Create alerts for stoppages, route abnormalities, and idle times or access to restricted areas.

‍

9. Multi-type fleet complexity (diesel + electric)

Running a mixed fleet with some diesel and some electric vehicles sounds like one step toward sustainability, and so it is. Yet, it brings in a layer of complexity. If not well handled, it can put the teams under immense pressure.

‍

Here's the problem: Two fuel types, two sets of maintenance systems, and completely different behaviors. Range anxiety, charging downtime, battery health, or software issues are wholly unique to EVs. And yet, the majority of teams build the same procedures and tools around both. Meaning, there's poor tracking, badly managed utilization, and many service errors that should never have been there in the first place. Add to that very little training for EV drivers or field response protocols, and a single breakdown may become a logistical nightmare.

‍

What helps:

• Separate your fleet by van type (ICE vs. EV) and build specific SOPs for each.
• Track degradation trends and charging patterns to prevent mid-route failures.
• Construct or map out reliable charging infrastructure, including back-up options on the long routes.
• Train the ops teams and drivers on the EV side of servicing, charging safety, and energy-efficient driving.
• Plan your EV downtime around charging windows, and not based purely on the distance covered.

‍

10. Inability to scale across locations

Managing a fleet in two cities feels manageable. Add a few more and suddenly, what worked before starts to crack. Without standard processes, shared visibility, and unified branding, every new location adds friction instead of scale.

‍

Local teams usually set their own ways: packaging rules, driver protocols, or even service quality and reporting dashboards, but they are all different. Those who manage the fleets are then forced to be hands-on or firefighting across locations, without really seeing what’s going on in different cities. The risk? Your brand consistency and operational control get compromised, and, finally, you lose sustainable growth.

‍

What helps:

• Central dashboards featuring real-time data with city-wise filters so that HQ is able to perceive the bigger picture without losing local context.
• Located documentation of the SOPs and enforcing them across cities, from vehicle branding standards, upkeep, delivery protocols, to customer handling.
• Have safety checklists, reporting formats, packaging types, and dispatch processes standardized across locations.
• Appoint regional leads accountable to shared KPIs and not restricted to just their region.
• Use the same tech stack across all locations.
• Create a location onboarding kit with templates, training, and SLAs for faster scale without chaos.

‍

11. Budget leakages in maintenance, tech, and operations

‍

Hidden costs escalate rapidly as fleets expand. A minor monthly cost quickly turns into a huge budget for maintenance and tech subscriptions, or operational inefficiencies. Problem? Costs go up; there is no single person in the loop to know why.

‍

The high breakdown cost is accepted as "normal." One team used one tool, and the other team used another tool that does exactly the same thing. Old vans keep getting repaired instead of being retired. Having no maintenance versus replacement logic means decisions are made based on what feels right and not because of financial insight. 

‍

Here’s how you can solve this:

• Use past trends to forecast future spend, thus making it possible to plan for upgrades or replacements before they become a cost emergency.
• Set monthly cost ceilings per van. This ensures every vehicle has an upper limit for maintenance, fuel, and tech.
• Set replacement thresholds based on historical data for maintenance (for instance, if maintenance costs exceed 70% of the van's value, it's time for replacement).
• Audit the tech stack every quarter and get rid of any unused licenses.
• Keep ROI per route or van in check
• Set budget alerts to inform ops managers whenever a van or team crosses a monthly threshold.

‍

12. Technology adoption gaps

Introducing new tech into a van fleet sounds exciting, until it remains almost unused. Here is the grim reality check: Operations teams usually stick to what they know; drivers try not to download yet another app, and you are left spending on something underutilized despite 75% of drivers using a mobile driver app.

‍

Most fleets don't have a problem with tools; they have an overabundance of tools that don't talk to each other, or there's the unfortunate case of a system being introduced into an environment without any context, with no training, or with new duties forced upon the workforce with no input. In fact, as per statistics, 46% of fleet leaders report using more than ten separate tools to manage operations. The end result is that the data remains in silos, workflows remain manual, and the business continues to run off spreadsheets even after investing in software.

‍

The Solution:

• Start with 1-2 integrated platforms that really need to address immediate pain points (e.g., routing + driver tracking).
• Introduce the solution in waves, as opposed to a complete rollout in one go. Let the pilot groups from ops and driver teams test and give feedback.
• Share success stories internally of how workload reduction, quicker dispatch times, or fewer calls have been attributed to the new tools.
• Train drivers with mobile-first onboarding—video, voice instructions, or simple walkthroughs work better than 80-page PDFs or that classic "sit at your desk" training session.
• A tech champion needs to be assigned to each location-who can support their colleagues and escalate issues during the transition.
• Keep a track of the tool usage. Catch drop-offs and retrain your team if needed. 

‍

Pro tip: Take a look at the top fleet management technologies you can try! 

‍

Cybersecurity challenges: 

And one more concern you shouldn’t be overlooking is cybersecurity! 

Let me give you two recent examples.

‍

Retailers Marks & Spencer and the Co-op fell prey to a third-party payroll provider. While the core logistics systems stood outside the purview of the breach, such an incident greatly raises issues such as phishing threats, reputational damage, and exposure of supply chains.

‍

The ransomware attack at Peter Green Chilled in Somerset brought about more devastation to its temperature-controlled logistics: it completely took down the IT systems and suspended all operations of food delivery to quite a few food retailers in the UK. It compromised core functions such as route planning, vehicle telematics, and cold chain control, resulting in financial and operational losses from the spoilage of goods.

‍

The past several cases have sounded warning bells: Cybersecurity is no longer an option; it is a must-have.

‍

Solution: 

• Train all your employees on the basics of cybersecurity.
• Create strong passwords while enabling 2FA on all fleet apps, devices, and dashboards.
• Include clauses in all contracts requiring notifications in case of a breach, along with means and protocols for the protection and cure against cyber incidents.
• Back up important systems (such as dispatch software, GPS tracking, maintenance logs) on a regular basis, and have these backups stored in secure, preferably offline environments or on the cloud.
• Take the latest security patches and software updates without any delay, whether for administrative or in-vehicle systems such as telematics and tablets.
• Design the internal network in such a way that routing, telematics, and financial systems are separated from the general-use network.
• Have access restricted on a role-based level, including for those working from home, contract drivers, and third-party service providers.
• Endpoint protection programs that monitor all malware or unauthorized access or suspicious behavior of the fleet-linked devices would be best.
• In case you are dealing with larger fleets, install a real-time SIEM (Security Information & Event Management) that has some customization for logistics or fleet use.
• Have a cyber incident response plan that outlines the step-by-step actions, backup contacts, and escalation procedures.
• Conduct regular drills and simulations of the actual response procedure, including your IT team, legal staff, and external partners.
• Register with a national cybersecurity body for threat alerting and assistance in incidents (e.g., NCSC for the UK, CISA for the US).

‍

13. Environmental regulations and ESG pressures

Regulators, consumers, and shareholders nowadays put such increased pressure on fleet operations to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Still, many such operations keep being reactive to such demands, not having a transition plan for EVs, no method of tracking their emissions, and no policies about eco-driving. Consequently, sustainability seems like something to check off rather than to strategize for, increasing the chances for penalties, hits to the brand image, and misdirected investments.

‍

What works:

• Build green-fleet roadmaps. Recognize high-density routes and start the conversion of those first, with hybrid or electric vans.
• Track emissions per mile via the usage of telematics and fuel logs as a method of holding people responsible.
• Apply for local or national EV incentives like the California-based port EV mandates or federal/state rebates to help price offsets.
• Driver training in eco-driving maintains gentle acceleration and minimizes idle time in relation to battery range.
• Make investments in suitable charging infrastructure at the depot and en route to ensure smooth operations.
• Set ESG performance targets, measuring them in sustainability dashboards—%EV on fleet, CO₂‑eq per mile, reductions year-over-year. About 15-25% EV adoption for 2025 seems to be a good fit for many top-notch fleet management agencies in the industry, and there is a target of making sure that the level of CO₂ emissions remains under 0.5kg per mile as the benchmark.
• Report goals and progress without laying any claims to stakeholders; link internal KPIs with driver incentives as to emission output. In case you’re wondering which KPIs to track, here’s a resource for you! 

‍

In May 2024, PepsiCo Beverages North America began operations with 75 Ford E‑Transit electric vans and 50 Tesla Semi trucks in California, part of a broader push to comply with the zero-emission mandates at ports and to achieve ESG goals before 2035 regulations come into force. It is one of the instances of real-world fleet adaptation to regulatory pressure and sustainability demands.

‍

‍

Source 

‍

14. Customer experience and SLA failures

John Moss, CEO of English Blinds, says:

“Keeping customers informed about where their goods are in the pipeline and when they can be expected in real time is one of the core tenets of providing a great customer experience, and the best way to achieve this is to integrate the appropriate tech.”

‍

Missed delivery windows harm customer satisfaction while inhibiting the timely arrival of products. B2B industries are fast-paced, and a van arriving late definitely starts the chain reaction: reviled customers, lost SLAs, and service penalties that increase in value. The biggest problem may not even be the delay itself, but the lack of visibility and communication when something goes wrong. Customers get frustrated, and account teams are left scrambling when updates are still manual, no live tracking exists, and data is scattered across dispatch systems. Therefore, effective communication is crucial in this regard. 

‍

The solution:

• Enable real-time notifications on departure, delay, and re-ETA for customers through SMS, email, or through a client portal.
• Geofencing and route tracking should be implemented to dynamically adjust SLA timers and issue alerts when prohibitive delivery windows might be breached.
• Integrate the FMS with one or more CRM systems so that the account manager can see delivery status in real time, instead of having to hand-hold the dispatcher in the call.
• Provide SLA dashboards based on routes, drivers, and customer segments. 
• Have some remote and instant warming systems that provide proof of delivery to your customers.
• Teach dispatchers and drivers to prioritize customer communications, especially when deliveries are urgent.

‍

15. Data silos and lack of actionable analytics

Managing a van fleet without integrated data? That’s one of the biggest fleet management challenges. I have been there; it is like flying blind in fog. The vans are out; deliveries are made, but it all happens with no real idea about costs, time leakage, or which routes are draining your ROI. Hence, you are into a scramble of sheets and tools, making half-baked decisions.

‍

Usually, it is not the lack of data. It’s very much there, but all scattered. Fuel consumption data resides in one system, maintenance logs reside in another, and delivery SLAs reside in yet another. Without a bird's eye view, you are addressing the symptoms rather than solving the underlying problems.

‍

Here’s the solution:

• Centralize all operational data into one dashboard-maintenance, fuel, routing, driver behavior, SLA compliance, cost-per-mile metrics.
• Build fleet-wide dashboards by van, route, city, and time for performance scrutiny.
• Run analytics to track trends of vans reaching retirement thresholds, peak idle times, and those that achieve the highest fuel efficiency scores.
• Get automated weekly across-the-board performance summaries-and don't give leadership raw numbers; give them insights.
• Allow cross-functional access so that ops, finance, and planning teams have one version of the truth.

‍

These solutions have been very helpful to me! Once I started consolidating all data points into one live view, we became less entrenched in seeing problems; rather, we saw patterns and made a shift from firefighting mode to chartering the future-proofing of the entire operation. That is where the real power of connected analytics in fleet management lies.

Tackle fleet management challenges like a pro!

These are some of the 15 main fleet management challenges commonly faced by van fleets as they scale, aim for profitability, or seek to meet customer expectations on a daily basis. Be it deliveries getting delayed, surging costs, or missed compliance checks, the list of issues seems to get longer with no mechanism in place to take care of them. 

‍

The good part is: when you start approaching these problems systematically, you do not just deal with delays or refuel costs but build a fleet that is able to do things quicker, with more predictability, and with less hassle. 

‍

Standardization of SOPs, transition toward digital compliance, and taking control of data offer you clarity. Training your drivers, improving your technology, and automating decisions will bring you consistency, thereby reducing customer complaints, maximizing ROI per van, and freeing up time for teams.

‍

Make the urgent fixes first. That would ensure momentum is gained fast. Real progress in van fleet management happens by tracking what is actually improving.